« Air Guitar Nation the movie? | Filmstalker | Directors Guild take hard stance »


Charlie Wilson's War changes history?

CharlieWilsonsWar.jpgWe're all used to hearing American cinema changing history for the convenience of a film plot, but it seems that the real life people behind the story of Charlie Wilson's War have been pushing for changes to the film.

The concern was that the film suggested the arming of the Afghanistan fight against Russia in turn armed Al Qaeda, something that I thought was stunningly obvious.

As far as I understand it, the rise of the anti-western feelings within Afghanistan came from the complete withdrawl of funds and promised support as soon as they pushed the Russians back out of the country, at that point they were left with a country ravaged by war, a war that was assisted by America.

It was after this that the Al Qaeda group rose up and began seating itself in power, assisted by various other countries, and began it's anti-western mantra.

So the story from WENN through Starpulse News Blog says that Joanne Herring, who is played by Julia Roberts in the film, was stunned when she first read the script by Aaron Sorkin as it implied that weapons they had helped supply the Afghanistan fighters with were then used by Osama Bin Laden and Al Qaeda – well wouldn't they have been? Did they instantly scrap them and start again?

Well Herring believes otherwise and she demanded that changes were made to the script, changes that were apparently granted. She says:

“Can you ever predict a war? The shelf life of a stinger missile is five years. There's no weapon we got them that can be used today.”

Well no, no one is saying that you can predict a war, however I think it was the pulling out and lack of support and aide after the war that gave rise to these feelings, and as for the shelf life of a stinger missile, well I'm sure they adhere to best before end dates, and shelf lives of other weaponry are much longer.

Don't get me wrong, I'm not going after the woman, but I do believe that the west had a duty to assist Afghanistan after the war, not just during it to give the opponent in the Cold War a bloody nose.

It remains to be seen if this implication is still there in Charlie Wilson's War, and if Hollywood has yet again changed history to either hide a negative aspect of it or polish up a positive. However I do find it hard to believe that Tom Hanks would apear in something that suggested such connections.



The film is laughable from a historic point of view and hard to watch by anyone who has studied the soviet afghan war.The soviet "toy bomb" myth is thrown in along with mention of Massoud and us support for him when in fact he received very little cia funds most came from Iran and China.
The most idiotic comment in the film is near the end when the cia man tells Wilson that the crazies started to flow in after the soviet pullout.Most of the fundamentalist leaders were born in afghanistan
and men like Gulidin Hekmatyar received the lions share of the aid the CIA provided.The cia gave the funds to the pakistani ISI and they doled it out to the most extreme pashtune suni groups who later took power as the Taliban with full pakistani and saudi suport.I will not even go into the Bin Laden thing except to say that Hekmatyar makes him look like a nice guy,never remember osama throwing acid in womans faces for not wearing full head scarves and that was in the 1980's.

Much as I thought then, not a good representation of real events and a typical Hollywood film effort to soften the truth and even disguise it. What is really needed is to see it in every detail and learn from it.


Add a comment


Site Navigation

Latest Stories



Vidahost image

Latest Reviews


Filmstalker Poll


Subscribe with...

AddThis Feed Button

Windows Live Alerts

Site Feeds

Subscribe to Filmstalker:

Filmstalker's FeedAll articles

Filmstalker's Reviews FeedReviews only

Filmstalker's Reviews FeedAudiocasts only

Subscribe to the Filmstalker Audiocast on iTunesAudiocasts on iTunes

Feed by email:


My Skype status


Help Out


Site Information

Creative Commons License
© www.filmstalker.co.uk

Give credit to your sources. Quote and credit, don't steal

Movable Type 3.34