« Stalker's Top Ten 2008: Louise McGregor: Worst Rumours | Filmstalker | Stalked: Bullock and Stallone, Boxleitner in Tron 2.0, The Wolf Man 2, Luhrmann's Gatsby »

Promotion


Slumdog Millionaire

Film Four Stars
Danny Boyle made a huge leap with this film Slumdog Millionaire, heading to India and Bollywood and leaving behind Hollywood and whatever you could possibly think to call the British film industry.

However it's already clear that his Slumdog Millionaire film is becoming a bit of a hit with the critics, but what about audiences? Well I attended a preview screening and I was surprised.

Plot.pngSlumdogMillionaire.jpgThe plot seems pretty simple, but the idea is very clever. The film sees a boy from the slums who has managed to enter into the Indian Who Wants to be a Millionaire as he proceeds through each of the questions in the competition, and answers them correctly.

Come the penultimate question the show concludes until the following day and he's taken away to be interrogated by the police, and that is actually where the film begins. He's held by the police and they work their way through a video of the show from that evening, stopping at each question and having the boy explain how he answered each question correctly, after all how can a slumdog reach the final question when laywers and doctors have failed before him?

At each question the boy recalls his past and explains how he came to know the answer behind the question, and at the same time discover something about his life, the relationship with the girl he fell in love with from an early age, and about India itself.


TheFilm.pngThe first thing that you notice about the film is that it's nothing like a film you would associate with Danny Boyle. This is very different and it marks another leap away from the stereotypical Boyle that most would associate with the director of Trainspotting.

He's already had 28 Days Later and Sunshine (Filmstalker reviews) which have pulled him away in two different genres, but still similar directions, but Slumdog Millionaire is off at a complete tangent and something you just wouldn't expect at all. The fact that it is co-directed by Loveleen Tandan.

Despite the change and the dual helming, the film is superbly directed and looks wonderful throughout, filled with great locations and superb production design, and the way the story is setup captured my imagination from the opening scene. It could have been completely in flashback, as the questions are being answered or any other number of ways, but the flashbacks through video to the questions and then in his mind and words to his past just fit the film perfectly.

The story begins back when the boy and his brother were orphaned at a young age during some anti-muslim attacks and follows through to the present day and beyond. It's during the younger period though that I found the most enjoyment with the film.

The performances of the two young actors are better than the corresponding performances of their adult counterparts in the latter half of the film, and the story itself has much more weight and dramatic impact during the first half of the film, again following the storylines of the younger characters rather than the older ones we see in the current story.

The dramatic threads concerning the brothers and the girl feel weaker and disconnected in the second half, you don't feel so attached and invested in the characters and how their stories play out, and I found that disappointing because during the first half I was enthralled in their stories and the friendship triangle, and the dramatic power of some of those scenes was very powerful.

For example the scenes where the two brothers meet again after all this time apart lacked the drama and tension that scenes such as the three children being in the unopened hotel carried. The moment where the older brother sends the younger out of the room is one of the strongest in the film and far outweighs the strength of any of the scenes with the older characters.

It's not that the scenes with the older characters aren't enjoyable to watch though, they just aren't as intense and powerful as the earlier scenes with the younger characters. To be fair though the relationship between Jamal and Latika does gain more importance and weight as the story progresses, just not the impact of some of those earlier scenes between them all.

Despite enjoying the younger actors more in the first half of the film, in the latter half I did have my favourites too. Irrfan Khan and Anil Kapoor as the Police Inspector and the host of the millionaire show are very well portrayed, and both dynamics between them and Jamal are well acted, directed, and written.

I found the story was well written throughout, although there were some contrived and unsurprising turns later on, particularly in the ending, I felt that it was forgiveable as I had bought into the fantasy and feel good elements of the film well beforehand. Some of the writing was extremely natural and very identifiable rather than being too fantastical and in the land of film make believe.

For instance the "phone a friend" moment was pretty contrived, and the way it brought the three characters together again through fate or luck was another very strong moment. Contrived yes, but very enjoyable and satisfying too? Definitely.

The screen writing is superb if I'm to be honest, the more I think back on the film the more I realise that the way the answers were explained was very well conceived and developed. Not only do we see more of Indian life, but we also watch the passage of time and the development of the three characters and their relationship. It's a great choice for the plot and it's a great way to tell the story.

It's in the power of some of the exchanges between characters at key moments in the film that really does the writing justice though, and it draws you in from the opening moments.


Overall.pngI really did enjoy Slumdog Millionaire. It's a wonderful story that you really will enjoy, and isn't one of these sickly sweet stories that is overly contrived. In that sense it's a little like It's a Wonderful Life, for with the feel good aspects of the story come some serious moments reality and drama that help even out the latter half of the film and provide for a much richer and satisfying journey for the characters.

With the great script comes great direction, superb locations and strong production design, making this a triumph of British and Indian film-making. This is perhaps the best showcase of Danny Boyle's, and Loveleen Tandan's, talents to date, and of the other talented names involved in the project, particularly the script from Simon Beaufoy adapted from the novel by Vikas Swarup (Amazon.co.uk / Amazon.com).

An excellent feel good film with plenty of drama, great characters and a superbly written script. Definitely one to become a Christmas favourite.


Buy or rent on DVD from LOVEFiLM
Buy the film, soundtrack and novel from Amazon.co.uk or Amazon.com
UK IMDB film details




Promotion


Comments

Great movie! Deserves the best picture award this year.

Nice reveiw.
I absolutely loved this movie, every bit about it and even though the ending was a little neat package I didn't roll my eyes, to me, it felt natural. I also loved, loved the end dance scene! This movie is definitely one of my favorites of the year.

Thanks Meli. Yeah, it was contrived, but in the same sense that something like A Wonderful Life is, and that doesn't get a rolling eye moment, you open your heart to it and accept it.

Some really interesting observations here. As regards the film being at times "contrived", I think I agree with Meli's comment - sometimes we over analyse films. Does it need to be clever and highbrow, so long as we ENJOY it? In any case, I enjoyed it adn can also highly recommend Vikas Swarup's "Q&A" - the book on which the film is based...

&... xxx

you havnt elaborated much on the triumph of British and Indian Film-making. i didnt intend to read this after watching the film. And i will 'Enjoy' any film that has tastefully done the classic heroic journey.

No I didn't, for me that wasn't much of an issue that even came to mind when watching the film, and probably that shows how well they've integrated the two.

For me it seemed that they were filming a western film in India with Indian actors, there didn't feel as though there was a huge coming together of the two film-making styles, although at the end there is a Bollywood dance number, but that feels as though it's something to close the credits with. Until that point I felt it was a western film wholly located in India.

Righto, I've joined the bandwagon, and totally enjoyed Slumdog Millionaire. I hope it gets Best Picture at any award giving body, a shoo in for the BAFTA BEst Picture maybe?

I just happened to see the movie before the Academy Awards results are declared.
1. The movie is nothing, but a standard documentary that describes only the darker, poorer aspect of India. Everybody in India and in the Third World ,seems to be a fraud from the police constable, a brother, and upto the top entreupreneur - the man who is hosting the TV show(Played by Anil Kapoor). Probably that is what the West would like to see in India;and that is what Danny Boyle has seen. Which is why, the movie is such a runaway hit in the West.
2. The Movie is an unabashed depiction of the Racist attitude of the white man and the West. Even after getting striped off all the parts of a Mercedes, the White tourist still shows benevolence by offering a $100 bill to the prime suspect and mutters - "look what we can do" or something to that effect. That it is extremely undigestible; I could well feel it, as I have travelled extensively in the Western world.
I hope to get some comments on that.
Arup Basu

I saw this movie for the first time less than a week ago. Good movie? Yeah, it's ok. But not the best movie of the year. I'd give that to the Brad Pitt movie.

I had never heard of this movie until after the 2009 Oscars when it walked away from the Awards stealing the show!! Then I saw it a few weeks later. It was OK. Now Avatar in 2010...that's gonna take it all!!

I FULLY AGREE that it is a good movie, no doubt about it, but it is highly overrated. If u people like this, there are 100s of other Indian Movies that are made much better than this(Both old and NEW). As for Rahman's music, it is GREAT (again no doubt). But this is definitely not his best. Pls go hear "dil se" and u'll know what i am talking about! Compare this movie to previous Oscar winners like American beauty, and well, u'll know wat i mean.

Verdict : To everyone who has still not seen the film, It's definitely a one time watch. Good music,Good story and Good (kind hearted if i may add) cast and crew. But i request you to watch it with an open mind. And by the way, Mumbai is not just a "slum area".

Promotion


Add a comment

(If you haven't left a comment on Filmstalker before, you may need to be approved before your comment will appear. Until then, it won't appear on the entry. Thanks for waiting.)

Tagline

Site Navigation

Latest Stories

Partner

Vidahost image

Latest Reviews

Promotion

Filmstalker Poll

Promotion

Subscribe with...

AddThis Feed Button

Site Feeds

Subscribe to Filmstalker:

Filmstalker's FeedAll articles

Filmstalker's Reviews FeedReviews only

Filmstalker's Reviews FeedAudiocasts only

Subscribe to the Filmstalker Audiocast on iTunesAudiocasts on iTunes

Feed by email:

Contact

TwitterFacebookSkypeLinkedInIMDB

Help Out

Site Information

Creative Commons License
© www.filmstalker.co.uk

Give credit to your sources. Quote and credit, don't steal


Movable Type 3.34