« Billy Connolly in Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows? | Filmstalker | Thai horror Body trailer online »


Tropa de Elite (Elite Squad) angers Brazilian police

TropadeElite.jpgThe Brazilian film Tropa de Elite (Elite Squad) has already been receiving a lot of press, mostly thanks to the Brazilian police who have been trying to stop the film from receiving its first screening at the Rio Film Festival this week.

Even before the film was seen in public a copy had been stolen during post-production and pirated, with the hype of the anti-police feeling and the messages it carried against many groups within the country, it was guaranteed an audience.

The film is a fictional one, so it's surprising that it has caused so much controversy, but it becomes apparent when the plot is revealed, and when you realise that the Director, José Padilha, based the film on interviews with real police officers.

It tells the story of two honest policemen who are disheartened working in the standard police force, a force that is underpaid, poorly equipped, and filled with corruption. They decide to leave the standard force and join the Special Operations Battalion, called BOPE, their officers are highly trained and painted as incorruptible, however they discover that they torture and murder suspect for information.

However it's not just police that the film hits out at, Reuters through Yahoo News tells us that it calls into question the social groups who work in the slums, the upper classes who fund crime through their drug habits, and the growing gulf between the rich and the poor which the society propagates.

The Director is firm to point out that this is not a vindication of the methods of the police, methods which some people think are acceptable in the face of growing organised and violent crime.

According to the story Rio police have been criticised for some time for their inhumane tactics, something I had heard little of before this story.

Filming was tough for that very reason, Padilha says that the police would try to stop filming and only intervention from the government allowed them to continue, then the only problem came from the criminal gangs themselves...

“We had part of the crew kidnapped, guns stolen, police raiding the slum, that almost killed the film and our costs soared.”

The film is a bleak view of law and crime in Brazil, but it is one that the Director and many supporters want to be told and seen, as he says himself:

“The film shows that the game has no winners when played under the current rules.”

You can find out more about the film from the official Brazilian site. There's only one trailer for the moment, but it does look like a powerful one.

For those of you in the know, the Director José Padilha is also responsible for the superb Ônibus 174 (Bus 174) (Filmstalker review), a film that tells a similar sorry tale of the lost children of Rio with some amazing real life footage of a bus kidnapping. It's a superbly crafted documentary and a very powerful film.

For me, knowing that the talent behind that film has crafted Tropa de Elite means I'm desperate to see the film. If you're in Rio, get to see that first screening.



Melhor filme do mundo !perfeito!
muito violento mas otimo e muito verdadeiroo!


excellent film. A bit of reality from Rio.

I'm excited to see that people are starting to see the film, maybe there'll be an international release coming soon.

For the English speakers among you, as I check all the comments I can I translated flavia's comment very roughly to:

"Best film of the world! perfect a good deal violent but optimism & a good deal real!"

I agree with flavia...
the best movie of the world...
very realistic
very chocking

its awesome

everybody have to see this movie...

Bus 174 a 'superb' film? I bet you wouldn't say that if it happened to YOU!!!!

Jose Padilha pandering again to the First World and what they want to see about Brazil. Padilha will now make whatever film he thinks will sell to the North American and European audience to make money! Sad.

Perhaps I wouldn't John, but it's still a superb film. What would you prefer, that it wasn't shown? I think it's an extremely powerful film with a stron message that needs to be told.

É nóis ! O Rio é isso ai mesmo! Só vendo pra crer.

It is nóis! The River is this ai same! Only seeing pra to believe.

Has anyone got any idea were i can buy tropa de elite with sub titles or in English. My mate from Rio said it was the best film about the Favelas. Just been to Rio and visited rocinha with www.bealocal.com. I miss Brasil and everyone in it!

Those people who say this film is:cliched Brazilian slum-porn, gun-porn and poverty-porn (Guardian England)
Have never lived in Rio.
They are as naive as the rich kids in the film

I hate the way the media keep using the word "porn" after everything just to make a genre of film sound evil and degrading.

Putting to the side how those words do not describe the mainstream pornography industy and so shouldn't actually be used in that way, it's just incredibly lazy writing and the irresponsible labelling of entire genres of film and of real world life.

Are they suggesting all Brazilian poor are evil and degrading? Using the term in reference to people in the same way that they are trying to label horror films as evil is pretty evil and degrading itself.

Using their terminology, are they "media-porn"?

Sorry for the off topic rant, that just makes me angry.

Everybody in Brazil likes this movie. Rich and poor people. As Padilha said: it's not a matter of winners and losers. There's no winners. Everybody loses. But the movie is awesome, one of the best i've seen lately. A must see!!


Add a comment


Site Navigation

Latest Stories



Vidahost image

Latest Reviews


Filmstalker Poll


Subscribe with...

AddThis Feed Button

Windows Live Alerts

Site Feeds

Subscribe to Filmstalker:

Filmstalker's FeedAll articles

Filmstalker's Reviews FeedReviews only

Filmstalker's Reviews FeedAudiocasts only

Subscribe to the Filmstalker Audiocast on iTunesAudiocasts on iTunes

Feed by email:


My Skype status


Help Out


Site Information

Creative Commons License
© www.filmstalker.co.uk

Give credit to your sources. Quote and credit, don't steal

Movable Type 3.34